Frontera Energy: High-Yield Value Play Despite South American Shenanigans
Is a pipeline sale about to happen?
Despite a checkered past and recent setbacks, Frontera Energy Corporation (TSX: FEC, OTC: FECCF) presents a compelling investment opportunity for value investors with a high risk tolerance.
The combination of substantial reserves, undervalued infrastructure assets, and an eye-popping recent yield creates a potential value proposition that shouldn't be overlooked, even considering the company's baggage.
The Shadow of Catalyst Capital: A History of Controversy
Before diving into the investment thesis, we must acknowledge the elephant in the room: Frontera's controlling shareholder. The Catalyst Capital Group and its partner owns approximately 54% of Frontera Energy, making it by far the company's largest shareholder.
Catalyst's history is littered with controversial litigation. One only needs to google “Catalyst Capital Litigation” to see red flags. For the sake of brevity, we won’t focus on these issues and let you come to your own conclusions on if you are comfortable with the management of this company.
The Guyana Debacle: A Costly Misadventure
Frontera's joint venture with CGX Energy in Guyana's Corentyne block now sits at the center of a legal dispute that threatens to erase years of investment (~$450 Million).
After making light oil and condensate discoveries in 2022 and 2023, the partners failed to complete an appraisal of the block in 2024 (per the interpretation of the Guyanese Government).
In February 2025, the Guyana government notified them that "the Petroleum Agreement and Prospecting License are at an end. By March 2025, the government officially canceled their license.
Guyana's Natural Resources Minister Vickram Bharrat was blunt in his assessment: "It's both a capacity and a financial problem... We have been very lenient with CGX, very helpful to them like we are with any company investing in Guyana, but there's a limit too."
The joint venture maintains that its interests and license remain valid, stating they are "prepared to assert their legal rights" if necessary. This legal battle adds another layer of uncertainty to an already complex investment case.
For the sake of investment and this write-up, one should view this as a $0 as it will take multiple years to litigate or arbitrate this matter presumably.
Financial Position: Debt Manageable, Earnings Improving
Despite these challenges, Frontera's financial position remains relatively solid. For 2024, the company generated an impressive EBITDA of $424 million.
As of December 31, 2024, Frontera reported:
Cash and cash equivalents: $223 million
Total debt: $493.8 million
Debt-to-EBITDA ratio: 1.17x
Frontera's 2024 production averaged 40,200 boe/d, peaking at 42,450 boe/d in Q4.
Note that Carlyle's SierraCol - currently being marketed for $1.5B - produces 45,000 boe/d. This company we would argue is of much lower quality than Frontera Energy in terms of the asset package.
Substantial Reserves Base: The Core Value Proposition
Frontera's oil and gas reserves provide a solid foundation for valuation.
As of December 31, 2024, the company reported:
Proved Reserves (1P):
Total: 100,212 Mboe (gross)
Net Present Value (10% discount, before tax): $2.26 billion
Proved + Probable Reserves (2P):
Total: 150,665 Mboe (gross)
Net Present Value (10% discount, before tax): $3.39 billion
These reserves are located primarily in Colombia with a small position in Ecuador.
The company's Proved Developed Producing (PDP) reserves have an NPV10 of $942.8 million, while Proved Undeveloped (PUD) reserves are valued at $1.13 billion.
Given Frontera's current market capitalization of ~$377 million, the company trades at a significant discount to its reserve value, a common situation for Latin American producers but one that represents potentially large upside for investors.
Noting the value Carlyle is trying to achieve, there is a huge disconnect here.
Undervalued Infrastructure Assets: Hidden Value
Beyond its upstream operations, Frontera owns significant midstream infrastructure that doesn't appear to be fully valued by the market:
96.55% ownership of Puerto Bahía, a Colombian maritime liquid bulk and dry cargo terminal
35% stake in the 146-mile Oleoducto de los Llanos Orientales pipeline
The chairman of the board recently announced the following:
“During the year, the Company's Infrastructure business generated $107 million of Adjusted Infrastructure EBITDA, and achieved several key milestones, including the announcement of a new LPG joint venture with Industrias Gasco and the construction of the Reficar connection, which is expected to be operational by the second quarter 2025. Importantly, Frontera's strategic review of its Infrastructure business is nearing conclusion, and the Company is analyzing various options and will communicate results in due course.”
And from a transcript of the 4Q 2024 call:
Cristian Fera
So, I have two questions. The first one, if you could please provide some color on the expected shareholder distributions for 2025 including both share repurchases and dividends?
And my second question is, if you have any news to share regarding the infrastructure business divestment?
Orlando Cabrales
Okay. On the -- I can take Rene the second one and you can take the first one. On the second one, as we announced it back in May of last year, I mean, we are working diligently to conclude this infrastructure process.
We are analyzing various options that we have right now. And we believe that the process as I think Gabriel mentioned in his remarks is close, is dealing in final stage. So, we hope to announce something soon. Rene, you can take the first one.
Cristian Fera
Thank you. And if I may a quick follow-up. Do you -- maybe it's a bit too early, but do you already know, what are your plans for the proceeds you're going to get off the infrastructure business divestment?
Rene Burgos
Yes. Look, I think as we said before in discussions with you all and in these conversations, capital allocation is the Board's remit. So, it really depends at the time and the form. Once this process is finalized, we will -- the Board will determine the most optimal way for this capital to be distributed. So, I guess like as Orlando said, we're nearing the end of the process. We're analyzing various options and as soon as we have better information, we'll communicate with the market in due course.
Infrastructure assets like these tend to command premium valuations compared to upstream oil and gas assets due to their steady cash flows and lower risk profiles.
Recent transactions in Latin American energy infrastructure have valued similar assets at 8-10x EBITDA, suggesting significant untapped value in Frontera's portfolio.
Even in the low case of 4-5X, it would be a hugely impactful to the market cap as these assets are currently valued at close to zero given the valuation of the E&P assets.
Guyana
While I previously mentioned these assets are worth zero at the current time, in the event of a successful litigation or arbitration in international court, there is a possibility of the company either getting back the asset or claiming damages in excess of its spend to date of $450 Million.
Unlike most of these type of litigations, Guyana has plenty of money coming in from Exxon development to seize in the event of a loss on their part.
Yield: Getting Paid While You Wait
Perhaps the most immediate reason to consider Frontera is its extraordinary yield.
In 2024, the company distributed $1.27 per share to shareholders. Based on the current stock price of approximately $6.68, this represents a yield of nearly 19%.
This yield provides a significant cushion against downside risk and compensates investors while they wait for the company's longer-term value to be realized through asset sales or other strategic actions.
While the actual dividend is quite small compared to companies like EcoPetrol and Petrobras, the company has been using tenders to return capital to shareholders.
Of course, 2024 could be an exception year, but it seems like the company has gotten the memo on not spending anymore money on boondoggles they are ill equipped to manage like HPHT offshore drilling in frontier basins.
Conclusion: Potential for Significant Upside Despite the Risks
After years of controversial ownership practices and the recent money-losing adventure in Guyana, there are signs that Frontera may have finally "found religion."
The company's reecnt robust dividend yield suggests a commitment to returning capital to shareholders, while its strategic reviews indicate a willingness to pursue value-maximizing transactions.
If Frontera successfully divests its infrastructure business at a premium valuation and then pursues a merger of its upstream operations with another regional player, the stock could potentially deliver 2-3x returns from current levels.
If you enjoyed this write-up, please like and share. I don’t get paid to do this, so consider that my reward.
Also, if you have other ideas I should write about, my DM’s are always open on substack and Bluesky :)
All writeups are subject to our TOS
This is a fantastic breakdown—sharp work balancing the red flags with the underpriced fundamentals.
What stands out to me is how well you framed the optionality layers in this thesis. You're essentially buying proven reserves at a fire-sale price, getting a high-yield while you wait, and still have potential upside from litigation (Guyana), infrastructure monetization, or even a strategic M&A play.
One thing I’d love to hear your take on: how do you think the market would respond to a successful infra asset sale? Does it trigger a rerate, or do you think the Catalyst baggage still weighs down multiples regardless?
This one brings memories, bought it at the covid lows, and the infrastructure assets were already a hidden asset then... and the only thing that came out of it since was further investment in Puerto Bahia (which is only profitable due to Frontera's own use of it, IIRC) and ceding one of their pipeline ownerships to settle a conflict with one of the statal companies.
Cheap enough to be worth it at this point though, will have another look!